The Enduring Resonance: Unpacking the ‘Uselessness‘ Myth of Chinese Culture in the Modern World374

The proposition, "[Chinese Culture is Useless]," as a bald statement, is jarring, provocative, and at first glance, deeply misguided. It’s a declaration that risks dismissing millennia of human endeavor, wisdom, and aesthetic accomplishment with a flippant wave of the hand. Yet, beneath the shock value of such a title lies a fascinating, albeit uncomfortable, question. It reflects an anxiety, a debate, and sometimes a dismissive attitude that Chinese people themselves, and indeed the world, grapple with. In an era obsessed with immediate utility, economic output, and digital efficiency, where does the profound, often abstract, value of culture truly lie? Is classical poetry less "useful" than a coding language? Is traditional etiquette a hindrance in a fast-paced global business environment? As a student and admirer of China, I find this question not just rhetorical, but a potent lens through which to examine the very essence of cultural relevance in the 21st century.

The sentiment that Chinese culture might be "useless" often stems from several modern pressures and misunderstandings. Firstly, there’s the relentless march of technological progress and globalization. In a world increasingly homogenized by Western-centric industrial and digital standards, traditional practices can seem anachronistic. Why study calligraphy when digital fonts suffice? Why delve into ancient philosophical texts when immediate answers are available through search engines? The perceived "usefulness" in this context is often narrowly defined by its direct economic applicability or its contribution to scientific advancement. If a cultural artifact or practice doesn't directly boost GDP or innovate a new product, it might be relegated to the realm of "quaint" or "obsolete."

Secondly, there’s an internal struggle within China itself. Generations that experienced the Cultural Revolution, or witnessed China’s rapid economic transformation, have sometimes viewed tradition as a burden, a brake on progress, or a source of past suffering. The May Fourth Movement, over a century ago, famously called for a rejection of traditional culture to embrace "Science and Democracy." This tension between maintaining a rich heritage and embracing modernity is a perpetual dialogue within Chinese society. Younger generations, immersed in global pop culture, sometimes find their own traditional art forms and philosophies less accessible or appealing than their Western counterparts, leading to a sense that these traditions are losing their practical grip on daily life.

Thirdly, for outsiders, the sheer depth and complexity of Chinese culture can be intimidating. With a recorded history spanning over three millennia, a language that requires immense dedication to master, and philosophical systems that are nuanced and often paradoxical, engaging with it demands significant intellectual investment. In a world of soundbites and simplified narratives, many might find it "easier" to dismiss what they don't immediately understand as irrelevant, or indeed, "useless," because its utility isn't immediately apparent or digestible.

However, to succumb to this superficial understanding would be to commit a profound error. Chinese culture, far from being useless, is an indispensable and dynamic force, shaping not only the lives of 1.4 billion people but also making increasingly significant contributions to global discourse and aesthetics. Its utility, rather than being immediate and quantifiable, is deep, pervasive, and often subliminal.

At its most fundamental level, Chinese culture provides an unparalleled foundation for national identity and social cohesion. What binds such a vast and diverse population together, across provinces, dialects, and socio-economic strata, if not a shared history, a common narrative, and a collective understanding of values and aesthetics? The Chinese language itself, with its ideographic characters, is a living museum of cultural evolution, connecting modern speakers directly to ancient texts and thought. Festivals like Chinese New Year, Dragon Boat Festival, and Mid-Autumn Festival are not merely holidays; they are vital arteries through which familial bonds, community spirit, and historical memory are continuously refreshed and reinforced. These shared rituals and narratives instill a sense of belonging and continuity that is invaluable, especially in an era of rapid change and dislocation. Can one put a price on collective identity? Is the sense of belonging "useless"?

Beyond identity, Chinese philosophical traditions offer profound ethical and governance frameworks that remain remarkably relevant. Confucianism, with its emphasis on harmony, filial piety, social order, self-cultivation, and benevolent governance, has shaped not just individual conduct but also political thought and bureaucratic structures for millennia. While often criticized for its hierarchical tendencies, its core tenets of empathy (恕, shù), righteousness (义, yì), and propriety (礼, lǐ) provide robust moral compasses. Taoism, advocating balance, living in harmony with nature, and the fluidity of existence, offers a counterpoint to Confucian rigidity, promoting spiritual well-being and a nuanced understanding of the world’s complexities. Buddhism, deeply integrated into Chinese culture, provides pathways to mindfulness, compassion, and inner peace. These aren't just historical doctrines; they inform modern Chinese perspectives on leadership, environmentalism, interpersonal relationships, and mental health. When global leaders grapple with ethical AI or climate change, are these ancient wisdoms truly "useless" in providing alternative perspectives to purely utilitarian or individualistic Western approaches?

Aesthetically, Chinese culture has gifted the world an astonishing treasury of artistic expression. Calligraphy, far from being just a means of writing, is a sublime art form, a dance of brush and ink that expresses the artist's spirit and mastery. Traditional Chinese painting (国画, Guóhuà), with its emphasis on natural landscapes, spiritual depth, and the interplay of empty space, offers a profound alternative to Western realism. Ceramics, opera, classical gardens, intricate embroidery, and traditional music are not merely decorative; they embody centuries of meticulous craftsmanship, philosophical principles, and a unique way of seeing the world. These artistic forms are not static relics; they continue to inspire contemporary Chinese artists, designers, and architects, fueling a burgeoning creative industry. The "Guochao" (国潮) movement, a resurgence of national pride that fuses traditional Chinese aesthetics with modern fashion, product design, and branding, is a testament to the vibrant utility of these cultural elements. To experience beauty, to be moved by art, to find solace in design – are these truly "useless" endeavors in the human experience?

Moreover, in the realm of global soft power and diplomacy, Chinese culture is an increasingly vital asset. As China takes on a more prominent role on the world stage, its cultural exports – from cuisine and films to literature and traditional medicine – act as powerful bridges for understanding and mutual respect. Confucius Institutes, while not without controversy, serve as platforms for language and cultural exchange, fostering connections that transcend political differences. The very distinctiveness of Chinese culture offers a unique narrative and an alternative perspective in a world that often benefits from diverse viewpoints. When China seeks to engage with other nations, its cultural heritage provides a rich tapestry of shared values (like the emphasis on harmony and collective good), historical precedents, and humanistic principles that can facilitate dialogue and cooperation. Is diplomacy, aided by cultural exchange, "useless"?

Finally, and perhaps most importantly, the enduring nature of Chinese culture is a testament to its inherent strength and adaptability. It has survived countless dynastic changes, foreign invasions, internal upheavals, and ideological shifts. It has absorbed elements from other cultures (like Buddhism from India) and transformed them into something distinctly Chinese. This resilience speaks not of uselessness but of a profound, living utility. Culture is not static; it evolves. The "usefulness" of Chinese culture today is found not just in its ancient forms but in its capacity to adapt, to inspire new creations, and to provide context and meaning in a rapidly changing world. The debates about what to preserve, what to modernize, and what to reinterpret are signs of a living, breathing culture, not a dying one.

In conclusion, the assertion that Chinese culture is "useless" is a superficial judgment that misses the forest for the trees. It’s a statement born of a narrow, often economically driven, definition of utility, and a fundamental misunderstanding of culture's pervasive and profound influence. Chinese culture is not a mere collection of ancient artifacts or quaint customs; it is the very fabric of identity for a quarter of humanity, a wellspring of ethical wisdom, an inexhaustible source of aesthetic inspiration, and an increasingly important tool for global engagement. Its utility lies not always in quantifiable outputs, but in the qualitative enrichment of human experience—in fostering belonging, guiding moral choices, inspiring beauty, and building bridges across divides. Far from being useless, Chinese culture is an indispensable, dynamic, and enduring force, its resonance growing ever stronger in a world that increasingly seeks depth, meaning, and connection.

2025-10-13

Previous：Taishun, Zhejiang: China‘s Ancient Bridges, Mountain Heritage, and Living Traditions

Next：Unveiling the Soul of China: A Comprehensive Journey Through Its Enduring Culture